ashys5 Posted July 11 #51 Posted July 11 Do you think the "greatest" means most rings or more like who pushed the whole league forward, caue Shula’s unbeaten season always gets slept on and he coached forever without ever having a losing record somehow.
nixo3e7gh7b Posted July 11 #52 Posted July 11 belichick still teh goat for me ngl, but bill walsh deserves way more love too ?
legacyerra Posted July 11 #53 Posted July 11 Everyone forgets Paul Brown literally invented film study and the modern playbook, without that foundation Walsh or Belichick wouldn’t have had a starting point
zyxund9 Posted July 11 #54 Posted July 11 Do rings even matter if you walked into a rady made roster?
vexund Posted July 11 #55 Posted July 11 hard to argue against belichick's rings but i always felt like don shula gets slept on a bit that consistent excellence across different eras with totally different rosters was insane
gauzeayssa Posted July 12 #57 Posted July 12 Everyone fixates on rings but i kinda think Don Shhula deserves more love, the guy had the only perfect season and sustained success across two completly different eras of the sport without leaning on a single quarterback his whole career
larsalan Posted July 13 #58 Posted July 13 Vince Lombardi straight up owned those championsips with a playbook everyone saw coming, the power sweep was basically a cheat code that still worked in bad weather when the odds were stacked against him
frostolesse Posted July 13 #59 Posted July 13 I'd pick Walsh over Lombardi cause one innovated the entire passing game and the other just perfected power runnin
xorurique277 Posted July 13 #60 Posted July 13 Lombardi's teams ran liike five plays but nobody colud touch the execution on em
hal2ify7t7 Posted July 14 #62 Posted July 14 Rings alone don't tell the whole story, I'd take Walsh's lasting schematic fingerprints over Belichick's trophy case because everyone still runs his concepts but nobody can replicate the Patriot Way without Brady.
enriquenadan Posted July 14 #63 Posted July 14 Belichick wont because he evolved the defense to match whatever the league threw at him.
Karlsully Posted July 15 Author #64 Posted July 15 On 7/13/2026 at 8:33 PM, frostolesse said: I'd pick Walsh over Lombardi cause one innovated the entire passing game and the other just perfected power runnin "Just". Using the word just followed by perfected? hmm. Different styles but both respectable
Featured Comment
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now